Congratulations, you just showed me a great photo. Now I have a question: how many photos did you take before you took that one?
We professionals like to pretend we're perfect. Every image we take is great. That's why we're a pro, right?
Not even remotely true.
I tell a story about one three-week trip to the Cordillera Blanca in Peru that I did with Galen Rowell back in the mid-90's. As it turned out, after landing back at SFO we both did the same thing: we each dropped off about 120 rolls of film to the same lab on our way driving home from the airport.
This led me to ask Galen a question: "So how many keepers do you think you have?"
Galen's answer was more nuanced and deeper than I expected. This quickly turned into an invitation to come join him as he went through his images after they returned from processing the next day. No need to ask me twice.
Galen Rowell was a renowned adventure photographer, an early Nikon Ambassador (before they were called Ambassadors), and whose work appeared in National Geographic and many other publications.
So first a number: 120 rolls of 36 exposure film equals 4320 images.
Galen had a very large light table he worked over, with a very large box next to it (if my memory is correct the box was something like 3 feet by 3 foot by 3 feet tall). That box was filled with "rejects." I don't ever recall him emptying that box, though it must have happened a few times. When I asked him about it, he said it was there as a reminder. A reminder that he wasn't perfect, a reminder that every image cost him (these days that would be more in time and effort than money), and a reminder that he shouldn't be trying to keep everything.
The A Images
As Galen looked through images with me hovering over his shoulder, he explained that his expectation would be that there might be something near 100 images he'd call A images. A images were ones that he wanted to work on more because they were the best of the bunch and they would end up as gallery prints, and/or they were the ones he chose that were destined for book or magazine projects that he was working on (a couple of years later that included projects that I assigned Galen in my role running a media group at Rodale).
So, 100 out of 4320. That's 2.3%.
The B Images
Another couple hundred or more images ended up in his B pile on the light table, which were photos that his stock image staff managed. I could always tell when Mountain Light, Galen's company, was sending Rodale images from the B pile: we just got the original slide. Most of Galen's A group ended up being converted to medium format internegatives and slides. Why? Because, among other things, on our publication's light table, a 35mm slide doesn't look nearly as impressive as something a MF or large format pro was submitting.
So, let's say 500 more images out of 4320 went into the B pile (I didn't count exactly for that trip; that's the rounded figure I remember). That's another 11.6%. Another way to put this is that about one in eight of Galen's original photos from that trip in Peru ended up in places where they might get published.
The C and F Images
Most of the rest ended up in the reject box next to the light table. Some of those images appear to have been scavenged from the box when his wife and business manager Barbara made a deal with Corbis for his non A or B works.
During my time with Galen during his edit, he did have a large pile of images that weren't A or B, but hadn't yet made it to the Box of Shame. I suspect that someone on staff later went through that extra pile and graded them C (retain) or F (Box of Shame).
The Takeaways
Where am I going with this?
Two places.
First, when I do the same thing with an amateur or enthusiast photographer these days, I often find that the great image that they showed me is actually one of hundreds, sometimes thousands that were taken in pursuit of it.
Indeed, there have been times when I've asked to see the "whole set of imagery" that ended with that prized image, and I get a resounding "No!". That's usually because the person is embarrassed at how many photos it took to get the winner they showed.
But this is useful and instructive information to know.
It should be obvious that you can be completely random with photography. That you take 100,000 photos and yes, wow, one of them is fantastic! As they say, a broken clock is right twice a day.
Your "hit rate" tells you something. If you track it over time, it tells you more.
Let's say that you go to the Cordillera Blanca and take 4320 images. How many really make it into a collection that you're truly willing to show everyone? 43? Great, your hit rate is 1 in a 100. (Be realistic here: self-editing is difficult, but you need to learn to be ruthless.)
A lot of folk think that the way to get more than 43 good photos from such an expensive and exotic trip is to increase the frame rate of their camera: take more images! Bracket! Zoom more! I'd say no for most subjects (though read on). All you're trying to do in that case is trying to take advantage of randomness. Take enough photos and one is bound to be good. You're not improving as a photographer, though.
Someone who is improving as a photographer will look close at their hit rate and start trying to make that better: 1 in 75, 1 in 70, 1 in 65, etc...
If you don't do that, what happens is that you end up with terabytes of images to import and sort through over time. Moreover, you spend way more time going through images after a session than it took you to get there, do the photographing, and come back. So conquer your FOMO (fear of missing out) and get more in control of what your camera is doing and why.
Second: the corollary is that it's unrealistic to think that every image is going to be great. Oh, I'd argue that it should still be properly exposed, focused, and decently composed, but the best of us obsess about small things to make great images:
- is the wing position the best it can be (birds in flight photos)
- are the runner's feet off the ground (sports images)
- is that the best smile of the bunch (portraits)
- is the framing exactly right for the subject (landscapes images)
- and so on
In order to get to this fine level of obsessing over details, sometimes you do have to photograph more, not less. Personally, I love repeating situations—e.g. an Osprey that keeps returning to its nest to feed its young—because it allows me to make different decisions and try to get my timing just right. One of the hundred photos I take in that situation is going to be better than the rest because I was given repeated chances to make different decisions. (Of course, figuring out which one often drives me crazy. But if I pay attention, it informs future decisions in the field.)
Time for an Assignment
Next time you go out on a purely photographic mission, whether it be the zoo, a workshop, or a vacation, take the time to try to work out your hit rate:
- What is your hit rate?
- Why do you think that's what the hit rate is?
- Would others agree that's your hit rate? Why or why not?
- Do you think you can improve your hit rate?
- If you think you can improve your hit rate, how are you going to go about that?
I'm a huge fan of "always learning." To do that, you have to be self aware, and to be self aware you also need to do some analysis. So start your journey with some analysis of how you're doing as a photographer. If you've been collecting stuff into Lightroom, perhaps even start walking back in time and attempt to see if you've improved.
Some great images come quickly to the prepared. Some great images take time to work out and create. For landscape photographers, for example, you might find the right place and composition, but it might not be the right light or time of year.
Finally: I don't really care how many images you need to take to get the great ones. I do care that you're working at getting more consistent and productive in obtaining great images.
Wrapping Up
Congratulations on taking a great photo! Now do what you can to increase the chance that you get another.
One reader of the original version of this article suggested that their hit rate was really high. Almost every image they took went in the "keeper" box for them, apparently.
I'd argue that if your hit rate gets too high, you're not pushing yourself enough. You've essentially codified your photography into a very narrow, repeatable process. I'd likely find that your composition is repeating, too, which means that after awhile, your next image looks like all your other images.
So there's a happy medium: you want to be experimenting and pushing yourself into new ideas and processes (which lowers your hit rate), but you want to improve your ability to come into a new scene or situation and get plenty of useful images (e.g. increase your hit rate).
Perfect hit rate numbers don't exist. But...
- If your hit rate is low, you need to think about and improve your craftsmanship (technique)
- If your hit rate is too high, you need to experiment and challenge yourself more